Nearly 1 in 3 Car Buyers Is Underwater on Their Loan — Here's How to Break the Cycle

If you've been making car payments faithfully for years and still owe more than your vehicle is worth, you're not alone — and you're not doing anything wrong. You've simply walked into one of the most common financial traps in the American auto market right now. In 2026, negative equity isn't a fringe problem. It's becoming the defining feature of how millions of Americans experience car ownership.

The Numbers Tell a Troubling Story

In Q1 2026, 30.9% of trade-ins toward new-vehicle purchases carried negative equity — the highest share for any first quarter on record. The average underwater trade-in now carries $7,183 in debt, up 42% compared with the same period five years ago.

To keep monthly payments manageable, a record 42.6% of underwater car buyers turned to 84-month, or seven-year, loans in Q1 2026. That's nearly half of all buyers in this situation stretching debt across seven years — paying interest long after their vehicle has lost most of its value.

The average monthly payment for a buyer rolling negative equity into a new loan reached $932, compared with $773 for typical new-vehicle buyers — a gap of $159 every single month.

Building your ideal collection? Create your own Dream Garage and design the lineup you've always wanted.

How People End Up Here

The pandemic set the trap, and now it's snapping shut. Many of these vehicles were purchased during the pandemic era at elevated prices. As vehicle values have normalized, more buyers are trading in cars that have plummeted in value since the shortage — leading to a surge in negative equity being rolled forward.

Read also: Car Insurance Claims Denied for Common Reasons — Policy Limits, Missing Docs, Lapsed Coverage

Jessica Caldwell, director of insights at Edmunds, put the risk plainly: "The biggest risk is you never get out of it, and it just keeps compounding. You could be buying a $30,000 vehicle, but because you're rolling over debt from your previous loan, you're now paying $37,000."

Ivan Drury, director of insights at Edmunds, added: "There's some hope in the sense that people are going to get better deals going forward for 2026 on their new car purchase. But the problem is that for the vehicle in their driveway, a lot of vehicles are losing value."

Want more car insights like this? Explore the latest stories in our Journal.

Five Ways to Get Out

The good news: there are real paths forward. Experts point to five strategies depending on how deep underwater you are.

1. Stay put and pay it down.

Bruce McClary, senior vice president at the National Foundation for Credit Counseling, says the first move for most underwater borrowers is simply keeping the car longer. After years of payments, depreciation slows and the loan balance eventually drops below the vehicle's value. Make extra payments toward principal when possible — even $50 a month accelerates the timeline.

2. Sell privately, not at the dealer.

McClary recommends selling your current car through a private sale rather than a dealer trade-in, since private buyers typically pay more — which can help you pay off more of the loan before moving to your next vehicle. Drury adds: "Shop it around" across multiple dealerships if a trade-in is necessary, since one dealer's offer may be meaningfully higher than another's.

3. Refinance for a lower rate.

If your credit has improved since your original loan, refinancing to a lower APR can redirect more of each payment toward principal rather than interest. The average APR for underwater borrowers in Q1 2026 was 7.9% — compared with 6.9% for the overall market. Even a one-point reduction can matter over a 72- or 84-month term.

Are you a dealer looking to reach serious buyers? Discover what CarCupid offers For Dealers.

4. Avoid rolling the debt forward.

Adding existing loan debt to new financing puts you underwater on day one. A 20% down payment on your next vehicle can offset the immediate depreciation that occurs in the first year and help prevent history from repeating.

5. Consider GAP insurance if you haven't already.

If your vehicle were totaled or stolen today, standard insurance would only pay market value — leaving you responsible for the difference. McClary advises shopping GAP insurance through your existing auto insurer rather than the dealer, where it is typically available at a significantly more affordable price.

Read also: Autonomous Vehicles Crash Twice as Often But Prove Safer Overall — 9.1 vs 4.1 Per Million Miles

The bottom line: negative equity isn't a life sentence. But rolling it forward without a plan is exactly how it becomes one.